Failure Risk Stays High, the Service-Charge Net Tightens, and Ground 1A Reaches a Judge
Issue #35 covers a thin but consequential week. The Regulator's annual report warns that landlord-failure risk stayed high; the government opened a multi-front assault on "rip-off" service charges and introduced the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill; a building-safety package landed in a single day; and the first reported Ground 1A possession case reached a judge. Our three Deep Dives trace how each development reaches into exempt accommodation through the authorities that already govern the sector.
Top 5 Roundup
1. Regulator warns landlord-failure risk "remained high" in 2025-26 as it publishes annual report and accounts
The Regulator of Social Housing has published its Annual Report and Accounts for 2025-26, alongside the minutes of its Statutory Advisory Panel. Inside Housing reports the headline finding that "the likelihood of both multiple and individual landlord failures remained high" across the year. The assessment lands directly on the supported-housing sector, where a disproportionate share of supported exempt accommodation is delivered by small, thinly capitalised or unregistered operators with limited liquidity and heavy reliance on volatile Housing Benefit income. For registered providers delivering exempt accommodation, the report reinforces the sustained regulatory focus on financial viability and governance, following a year of enforcement activity and the stability checks introduced for the smallest providers. Practitioners should read the report with the Advisory Panel minutes, which signal the regulator's forward policy direction.
2. Government moves against "rip-off" service charges as Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill enters Parliament
The government has announced reforms targeting "unfair" and "rip-off" service charges (Inside Housing), published updated guidance on the Tenant Fees Act as amended by the Renters' Rights Act 2025, and on 19 November introduced the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill — billed as "the beginning of the end" for the leasehold system. In Wales, the Welsh Government confirmed it will proceed with service-charge transparency reforms for leaseholders. Though framed around leasehold and the private rented sector, the cluster matters acutely for supported housing: service charges are the central mechanism through which exempt accommodation providers recover support, care and intensive-housing-management costs that sit outside capped core rent. Any tightening of reasonableness definitions, transparency duties or dispute-resolution rights could reshape how exempt charges are structured and evidenced.
3. Building-safety regime accelerates: Construction Products White Paper, Gateway 2 milestone, FRAEW guidance and new shut-off powers
A wave of building-safety activity landed on 19 November. MHCLG opened a consultation on its Construction Products Reform White Paper, with a companion consultation on a General Safety Requirement for currently unregulated products. The Building Safety Regulator confirmed it has now cleared more than 19,400 homes through Gateway 2 at a 92% approval rate (Inside Housing). Government also published updated guidance on Fire Risk Appraisals of External Walls (FRAEWs), and new enforcement measures allow gas and water to be switched off in blocks posing an "imminent risk to life." The package is directly relevant to supported-housing providers operating older, converted or multi-occupancy stock, where FRAEW and remediation costs already threaten scheme viability, and where vulnerable residents cannot easily be relocated if enforcement bites.
4. First reported Ground 1A possession case reaches a judge under the Renters' Rights Act
Nearly Legal has published one of the earliest reported accounts of a Ground 1A possession claim coming before a judge, contributed by Clara Hilger of Landmark Chambers. Ground 1A — the new mandatory possession ground where a landlord genuinely requires the property, introduced by the Renters' Rights Act 2025 — has been closely watched since commencement. Although the case is anonymised (A Landlord v A Tenant), limiting its precedential weight, it offers early practical intelligence on how courts are approaching threshold questions, evidence and procedure at first instance. For supported housing the live question is whether, and how, Ground 1A engages at all with the licence-based occupancy arrangements common in exempt accommodation — a threshold issue likely to generate its own litigation as the new regime beds in.
5. Youth and care-leaver policy momentum builds: Milburn response, Youth Matters Fund and Lifelong Guardianship rollout
Three threads converged this week around young people and care leavers — a core cohort in supported exempt accommodation. The government responded to the Milburn Review with a "new settlement for young people," which the Local Government Chronicle reports recommends "radical devolution" placing metro mayors at the centre of commissioning support for 16-25s. The Youth Matters Fund launched with a programme framework and local-authority grants under the Homelessness feed. And government announced the first-ever Lifelong Guardianship ceremonies for care leavers, with Lifelong Links rolled out nationally. Together they signal sustained cross-departmental attention to a group whose support needs underpin HB-exempt eligibility. Providers in mayoral areas should watch whether new youth commissioning structures create reclassification risk for — or new opportunities alongside — existing exempt provision.
Deep Dives
Deep Dive 1 — When the service-charge crackdown meets the exempt-accommodation funding model
The government's simultaneous moves against "rip-off" service charges, its updated Tenant Fees Act guidance, and the introduction of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill are being read, understandably, as a leaseholder story. For supported housing the stakes are different and arguably higher, because service charges are not a peripheral irritation in exempt accommodation — they are the architecture on which the entire funding model rests. Any reform that imports a general "reasonableness" and transparency regime into charges risks colliding with a Housing Benefit framework that has, for twenty years, treated supported-housing charges as a special case.
The starting point is the definition of "exempt accommodation" preserved by Schedule 3 paragraph 4(10) of the Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit (Consequential Provisions) Regulations 2006. That saving provision keeps alive the pre-2008 rules under which accommodation provided by a non-metropolitan county council, housing association, registered charity or voluntary organisation — where that body, or someone on its behalf, also provides the resident with care, support or supervision — is assessed outside the standard Local Housing Allowance and rent-restriction machinery. The practical consequence is that eligible rent in exempt accommodation can include "intensive housing management" and support-related service charges that would be stripped out, or capped, in the general-needs sector. It is precisely this headroom that the service-charge reforms now threaten to squeeze from a different direction.
The crucial legal point for practitioners is that there are two separate reasonableness tests in play, and they are not aligned. Under the Housing Benefit scheme, a service charge is eligible only where it is connected with the provision of adequate accommodation and is reasonable in amount — a test applied by the local authority as benefit decision-maker, with a right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. Under the leasehold regime, and the reforms now proposed, reasonableness is a landlord-and-tenant question tested through the property tribunal, focused on consultation, transparency and the recovery of actual cost. A provider could satisfy one and fail the other. The risk in the reform package is convergence: if transparency obligations and reasonableness definitions designed for leaseholders are extended across tenures, benefit authorities will have a new evidential benchmark against which to challenge exempt service charges that have historically escaped detailed scrutiny.
This is where the "real difference" test in Bristol CC v AW becomes central. That authority established that the care, support or supervision relied upon to secure exempt status must make a genuine, identifiable difference to the resident — it cannot be nominal, incidental or a label attached to what is really ordinary housing management. The Turnbull line of decisions — CH/150/2007, CH/4432/2006, CH/200/2009 and R(H) 4/09 — supplies the companion threshold: the support must be "more than minimal," must be provided to the claimant in that accommodation, and must be genuinely referable to the landlord or someone acting on its behalf rather than a third party operating independently. Taken together, these authorities already give benefit authorities the tools to disaggregate a provider's charges into genuine support and dressed-up management. A statutory transparency regime that forces line-by-line breakdowns of service charges would hand decision-makers a ready-made map for exactly that exercise.
There is a tension here that the reform debate has not surfaced. The policy instinct behind the "rip-off charges" announcement is consumer-protective: tenants and leaseholders should see what they pay for and should not be charged for services they do not receive. But in exempt accommodation the same transparency can cut against the resident's interest, because it may expose charges that — while genuinely incurred — do not survive the "real difference" or "more than minimal" tests once itemised. A provider whose support offer is thin may find that transparency accelerates loss of exempt status, HB restriction to the LHA figure, and a shortfall the resident cannot meet. Some of the sector's quieter operators have depended on precisely the opacity the reforms are designed to remove.
The Allerdale BC v JD [2019] UKUT 304 decision adds a further layer. It addressed whether support counts where it is provided by the landlord on its own behalf, and underlined that the statutory language — "by the landlord or a person acting on its behalf" — must be applied with care to the actual contractual and delivery arrangements. As providers respond to service-charge reform by restructuring charge schedules — unbundling support, re-labelling management, or routing provision through connected entities — Allerdale is a warning that formal restructuring will not save a charge if the substance does not meet the test. Benefit authorities and tribunals look through the paperwork to who actually delivers what, and to whom.
The practical implications are threefold. First, exempt providers should audit their charge schedules now, against both the HB eligibility test and the emerging transparency standard, on the assumption that the two will increasingly be read together. Second, the evidential burden is shifting: providers who cannot document that each charged element makes a real difference to the resident, and is more than minimal, are exposed regardless of how the leasehold reforms are ultimately drafted. Third, the Welsh transparency reforms are a live preview — MHCLG has previously followed Welsh leasehold initiatives, and providers operating across the border should treat Welsh practice as the likely template for England.
For Leonard's readers the message is not alarm but preparation. The service-charge reforms are not, on their face, aimed at supported housing. But the exempt-accommodation funding model has always lived in the gap between generous HB rules and light-touch charge scrutiny. As that scrutiny tightens across tenures, the gap narrows — and the old authorities, far from being superseded, become the sharpest instruments available to anyone testing whether a charge is genuine support or merely a price.
Deep Dive 2 — "Failure risk remained high": the regulatory perimeter and the exempt-accommodation blind spot
The Regulator of Social Housing's judgment, in its 2025-26 Annual Report, that the likelihood of both individual and multiple landlord failures "remained high" is not a routine piece of sector weather-reporting. Read against the regulatory architecture, it exposes a structural problem that the supported-housing sector has lived with for years: the operators most likely to fail are frequently the ones furthest from the regulator's reach. For practitioners, the report is an invitation to think hard about where economic regulation actually bites, and where it does not.
The RSH's economic regulation — the Governance and Financial Viability Standard, and the broader package of consumer standards now in force — applies to *registered* providers. Registration is the gateway. A provider that is a registered social landlord is subject to the regulator's grades, its stability checks, its enforcement ladder and its viability scrutiny. A provider that is not registered is, for economic-regulation purposes, largely invisible to the RSH, however many vulnerable residents it houses and however precarious its finances. This is the perimeter problem, and it is acute in exempt accommodation, where a large and shifting population of small, lightly capitalised operators — some charitable, some not — delivers supported housing funded almost entirely through Housing Benefit, often without ever registering.
The significance of the "failure risk remained high" finding lies in this mismatch. The report's concern is systemic: cross-subsidy models under strain, thin margins, exposure to interest-rate and cost pressures, and the fragility of providers heavily dependent on a single income stream. In the exempt sub-sector those conditions are the norm, not the exception. Yet the RSH's primary levers — downgrades, viability judgments, the power to compel governance change — reach only the registered minority. When an unregistered exempt operator collapses, the consequences fall first on residents and then on the local authority, which must re-house and may face Housing Benefit subsidy complications, while the regulator is a bystander.
This is the gap that the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023 was designed to close, and the Annual Report should be read alongside the slow progress of SHROA implementation. SHROA 2023 creates the architecture for a licensing regime and National Supported Housing Standards aimed squarely at the operators the RSH cannot currently touch — bringing local-authority licensing, rather than central registration, to bear on the exempt market. The tension the report lays bare is one of timing: the regulator is signalling elevated failure risk now, while the SHROA licensing machinery remains in consultation and is not yet operational. For a year or more, the sector sits in a gap between a registration-based regime that does not reach the riskiest operators and a licensing-based regime that is not yet switched on.
The Allerdale BC v JD [2019] UKUT 304 decision is instructive about why registration and HB status do not map neatly onto each other. Exempt status turns on the care, support or supervision provided by the landlord or on its behalf — a Housing Benefit question — not on whether the provider is registered with the RSH. A provider can be fully exempt for HB purposes, drawing enhanced eligible rent, while sitting entirely outside the RSH's economic standards. That decoupling is the core of the blind spot: the funding flows through the generous exempt route, but the viability oversight that should accompany public money at that scale does not follow it. The "real difference" test in Bristol CC v AW, and the "more than minimal" threshold in the Turnbull decisions (CH/150/2007, CH/4432/2006, CH/200/2009, R(H) 4/09), police the *quality* of support for benefit purposes — but they are tests applied case-by-case by benefit authorities, not a substitute for prudential regulation of the provider as a going concern.
There is a further tension between the consumer standards and the economic reality the report describes. The RSH consumer standards — covering safety, quality, transparency and tenant engagement — now apply to registered providers of supported housing, and the regulator has shown willingness to issue adverse consumer gradings. But consumer regulation presupposes a viable provider capable of delivering to standard. Where the underlying business is financially fragile, consumer enforcement can accelerate failure rather than prevent it: a downgrade that triggers lender nervousness or commissioner withdrawal can tip a marginal operator over. The Annual Report's dual message — high failure risk *and* continued consumer enforcement — sets up a genuine dilemma for the regulator, and providers should expect it to tread carefully where enforcement might precipitate the very collapse it is trying to avoid.
The practical implications for practitioners are concrete. Registered providers delivering exempt accommodation should treat the Annual Report as a signpost to intensified viability scrutiny and ensure their Governance and Financial Viability evidence is current, stress-tested and honest about Housing-Benefit dependency. Unregistered exempt operators should recognise that the SHROA licensing regime, once live, will subject them to standards they have not previously faced, and should not assume the current perimeter gap is permanent. Local authorities commissioning or placing into exempt accommodation should be alive to the fact that RSH grades tell them nothing about unregistered providers, and should build their own viability due diligence rather than relying on a regulatory badge that may not exist.
For my readers the central analytical point is this: the Annual Report is not simply a warning about a difficult financial year. It is evidence that the sector's risk is concentrated precisely where the strongest regulatory tool — RSH economic regulation — has the least purchase. Closing that gap is what SHROA 2023 is for; until it is operational, the exempt market's fragility will remain a problem the regulator can describe but not yet fix.
Deep Dive 3 — Ground 1A, the licence model and the security-of-tenure fault line in exempt accommodation
The first reported Ground 1A possession case to reach a judge, noted this week by Nearly Legal, is at one level a modest first-instance anecdote: an anonymised dispute, limited precedential value, a single judge working out how a new mandatory ground operates. But for supported housing it opens a question the Renters' Rights Act 2025 reforms have left unresolved and which will define litigation for years — whether the Act's new tenancy regime reaches the licence-based occupancy arrangements on which so much exempt accommodation depends, and what happens at the fault line where Housing Benefit law and security-of-tenure law pull in opposite directions.
To see why this matters, begin with how exempt accommodation is structured. The enhanced Housing Benefit treatment available under Schedule 3 paragraph 4(10) of the Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit (Consequential Provisions) Regulations 2006 turns on the provision of care, support or supervision — not on the legal form of the occupancy. But the two are correlated in practice. Many supported-housing providers use licences rather than assured or assured shorthold tenancies, partly because the support relationship and the need to move residents between units, manage risk, and retain flexibility sit awkwardly with full tenancy security, and partly because a licence can be presented as consistent with the "exclusive possession is qualified by the service offer" character of genuine supported housing. The licence model is, in other words, bound up with the support model that generates exempt status.
The Renters' Rights Act 2025 reshaped security of tenure for the mainstream rented sector: it abolished assured shorthold tenancies and section 21 "no-fault" eviction, converted the sector to periodic assured tenancies, and recast the possession grounds — introducing, among others, Ground 1A, the mandatory ground where the landlord genuinely requires the dwelling. The first reported Ground 1A case gives early intelligence on how judges approach the threshold: what evidence of genuine requirement is needed, how procedural compliance is tested, and how sceptically courts scrutinise a mandatory ground that could be used to circumvent the loss of section 21. For general-needs landlords this is the headline. For supported housing the prior question is whether the Act engages at all.
Here lies the central tension. If the occupancy is a genuine licence — no exclusive possession, or exclusive possession displaced by the service and support arrangements — the assured-tenancy regime, and therefore Ground 1A, may not apply, and the provider retains the greater flexibility a licence affords. But the test for whether an arrangement is truly a licence rather than a tenancy is a substance-over-form inquiry, and the same substance that defeats a tenancy must also be the genuine care, support or supervision that sustains exempt status. This is where the benefit authorities on the "real difference" and "more than minimal" tests become unexpectedly relevant to a security-of-tenure question. The "real difference" test in Bristol CC v AW, and the Turnbull threshold in CH/150/2007, CH/4432/2006, CH/200/2009 and R(H) 4/09, were developed to police HB eligibility — but they describe exactly the kind of substantive support that a court will look for when deciding whether an occupier is a licensee or a tenant. A provider whose support is real enough to satisfy the exempt-accommodation test is better placed to argue that the occupancy is a genuine licence; a provider whose support is thin faces a double jeopardy — loss of exempt HB status *and* reclassification of the occupier as an assured tenant with full Renters' Rights Act protection, including the Ground 1A apparatus.
Allerdale BC v JD [2019] UKUT 304 reinforces the point from the benefit side: the inquiry is into what support is actually provided, by whom, and on whose behalf, not into the labels the parties have chosen. Courts applying the tenancy/licence distinction after the Renters' Rights Act will adopt the same realism. The upshot is that the licence model is only as robust as the support that underpins it. Providers who have relied on licences as a device — attaching a nominal support offer to what is in substance ordinary letting — are exposed on both fronts simultaneously, and the arrival of Ground 1A litigation will accelerate the testing of these arrangements because tenants and their advisers now have a strong incentive to argue tenancy status and resist possession.
There is a policy tension worth naming for practitioners. The Renters' Rights Act's animating purpose is to enhance security and end no-fault eviction; the exempt-accommodation framework, by contrast, depends on flexible, often short-term, support-linked occupancy that lets providers manage move-on, risk and throughput. These are not easily reconciled. A supported-housing provider genuinely delivering care, support or supervision has a legitimate interest in flexibility that the mainstream reforms did not primarily have in mind. But the Act does not carve out a clean exemption for supported housing; it leaves the sector to rely on the tenancy/licence distinction and on specific grounds and exceptions, which means the boundary will be drawn case-by-case, in county courts, on the substance of each arrangement.
The practical implications are clear. Providers should review their occupancy agreements now, asking not merely whether they are labelled licences but whether the support actually delivered would persuade a court that the licence is genuine — the same evidence base that sustains exempt HB status. They should expect tenants facing possession to argue tenancy status and to invoke the full Renters' Rights Act regime, and should prepare their support records accordingly. And they should watch the emerging Ground 1A case law closely: each reported decision on genuine requirement, evidence and procedure narrows the room for manoeuvre.
For Leonard's readers the lesson is that the Ground 1A story is not a general-needs sideshow. It is the leading edge of a convergence between benefit law and housing law in which the same underlying question — is the support real? — now determines both whether the money flows and whether the occupier can be moved. The authorities that have long governed exempt status are becoming the authorities that govern security of tenure too.